What is Mutex vs. Semaphore in operating systems?

What is Mutex?

Mutex stands for Mutual Exclusion Object. Mutex is a particular kind of binary semaphore that is applied to control access to the share. Mutex involves a priority inheritance method to avoid advanced priority inversion difficulties.

Mutex allows current tasks with a higher priority to be kept in a locked state for the shortest possible time. However, priority inheritance does not correct the priority inversion; it only reduces its effect.

Why do we need Mutex?

A Mutex implements a mutual exclusion between a producer or consumer, which can hold the key (i.e. Mutex) and continue its job.

While the producer fills the buffer, the user must wait, and vice versa. In Mutex locking, only one thread can handle the whole buffer at a time.

Advantages of Mutex

Below are some of the advantages of Mutex.

What is Semaphore?

Semaphore is an integer variable that is commonly used by threads for process synchronization.

A Semaphore is a signaling method. A thread expecting a Semaphore can be signaled by the other thread.

A Semaphore uses two atomic processes:

  1. Wait

  2. Signal for process synchronization

A Semaphore permits or denies access to the resource, depending on how it is configured.

Why do we need Semaphore?

For a particular buffer, we can divide the 4KB buffer into four 1KB buffers. A Semaphore can be assigned to these four buffers, which enables users and producers to operate on separate buffers at the same time.

Advantages of Semaphore

Let’s take a look at some of the benefits of Semaphore below.

Mutex vs. Semaphore

Below are some of the main differences between Mutex and Semaphore.

Mutex

Data type
  • Object
Mechanism
  • Locking mechanism
Threads
  • Can have more than one program thread but not at the same time
Modification
  • Mutex object can locked or unlocked
Managing resources
  • The procedure has to wait if it is locked. It’s best to keep the procedure in a queue. This should only be accessed when the Mutex is unlocked.
Types
  • None

Semaphore

Data type
  • Integer variable
Mechanism
  • Signaling mechanism
Threads
  • Can have more than one program thread
Modification
  • Value is changed when wait() and signal() are used
Managing resources
  • If no resources are available, the process demands a resource to perform the wait action. It should wait until the Semaphore count is higher than zero.
Types
  • Binary and counting

Free Resources